Board - Thread
Next thread ->
Board -> English Forum -> Babylon 5 Mod -> Design feedback

Answers: 6
Page [1]

Posts: 972
# Thread - 2007-12-18 at 12:01 AM
I'm working on an new minbari ship, but this time I'm not sure about the design.
So i need some feedback from you.

It will be a ship which is bigger as the minbari transporter but much smaller as the Sharlin. Maybe some kind of Bomber or corvette.

What do you think about it? Is it enough minbari? Does it need more details? Any idea for the cockpitplace? Is the shape too simple? 6rb0.jpg

We are one!
Mighty Odin

Rock the board

Posts: 90
# Answer: 1 - 2007-12-18 at 12:12 AM
well i think it looks cool, "But" the back part can be somwath bether or diffrant, i saw them standing out a little wierd if i can say it like that.

sugjestion: i can see a fish tale look alike back there, with a good minbari tweek to it.

other wize i like the design and all the otehr things look fine and minbari clasick look a like.

Hope it helps you out.

Here is wath i meen,

Last edit by Mighty Odin at 2007-12-18 at 1:17 AM (3x Edited)

Going for pro

Posts: 586
# Answer: 2 - 2007-12-18 at 3:24 AM
I love the design it looks very Minbari like, the shape (With the thin back fins) makes it look like a very fast ship. My only suggestion is if it is a quite big ship (White star or larger) a few more fine details would be nice because at the moment it gives the feel of a small fighter. That said perhaps it may need nothing as textures can completely transform it.

Beautiful work as Always Amras

~R.I.P. Adam, my big brother 25/04/08~



Posts: 7
# Answer: 3 - 2007-12-18 at 4:05 AM
Overall it looks very good. More detail would enhance the Minbari "feel". What size would the ship be in relation to the Whitestar? I believe that the cockpit/bridge placement should be upper center mass (the hump on the top part)...but that would depend on the size of the ship. Looks good....nice work.

Thread author

Posts: 972
# Answer: 4 - 2007-12-18 at 10:31 AM
Ok, thank you all!
I will see what i can do.

Oh and Kasabian..... nice link^^

We are one!


Try to beat me

Posts: 121
# Answer: 5 - 2007-12-18 at 8:18 PM
Well its very Minbari like. As we know trasnports and fighters have their cockpits at the front where as larger ships tend to have C&C in the center and use a holo viewscreen. It would depend on how your planning on doing it. If it were the size of a white star I would agree with Pieman and have the cockpit some where near the top or perhaps half way up the forward hull.


Try to beat me

Posts: 149
# Answer: 6 - 2007-12-21 at 8:33 PM
Maybe as a corvette, it looks too mean to be a fighter class.

Personally I wouldnt have taken the Sharlin hull look I think that is best reserved for the Sharlin as its such a B5 icon.

In doing so though it certainly looks Minbari...and looks good too, mainly because the Sharlin is such a good looking ship.

Is that a good thing or a bad thing? I don't honestly know.

It looks like the USS Defiant of the Minbari fleet to my eyes.

Last edit by BigBANGtheory at 2007-12-21 at 8:38 PM (1x Edited)
Answers: 6
Page [1]

You must be registered.

Send password

No active vote

2018-04-13 at 9:57 AM
Original Agamemnon..
2017-07-18 at 12:04 AM
Bugs and issues re..
2017-07-15 at 8:36 AM
Babylon 5 Civlizat..
2017-07-11 at 4:23 PM
2017-05-11 at 11:41 PM
Schriftart in der ..
2017-01-13 at 10:09 AM
Immer her damit!
2017-01-13 at 9:56 AM
2017-01-13 at 9:50 AM
Was gefällt euch g..

no banners added

45 Online
818 Heute
544 Gestern
14.063 Monat
1.869.047 Gesamt

Wer ist online:

No data found.